I started writing this post about 8 times. And then I read a short article on a new book coming out entitled "The Birth Wars". This book by Australian Mary-Rose MacColl seemingly explains the exact predicament I find myself in. I'm am torn between the "natural" and the "medical" sides of a childbirth war - leaving me feeling confused, unconfident and ... crappy.
According to the article, MacColl breaks down the war between the "organics'' and "mechanics''. From the article: "In MacColl's parlance, the "organics'' are mainly midwives who believe birth is a natural process that has become overly medicalised, with the consequence that many women are traumatised by cold, clinical births, unnecessary caesareans and excessive medication. The "mechanics'' include many obstetricians and hospital clinicians, who believe birth is a risky, delicate process that must be carefully monitored to ensure women and babies are safe."
And there is no middle ground. And each side thinks the other is a bunch of dangerous idiots.
Yep, that about sums it up. She goes on to assert that it is the responsiblity of both sides of the war to get together and find some concensus so mothers and babies are safer ... and I can stop feeling so damn crappy and scared.
This is how I started my post 8 times ago...
Dear Ina May Gaskin,
I'm really enjoying your book "Guide to Childbirth". The first-person stories at the beginning were especially beautiful and inspiring. I love the idea of giving birth on some wacky commune/farm surrounded by peaceful hippie-women who have both amazing knowledge/skill and a magical ability to empower me during the sacred rite of childbirth. Yes, I would love to give birth in a dimly lit, comfy cottage (with a fire-crackling in the background)...naked and splayed out in all my glory on a big comfy bed....being massaged with neruli-infused olive oil by one hippie, while another gazes into my eyes willing me to push harder while remaining in a deep state of peace and transcendence. Okay, please sign me up.
Oh, wait, I don't live near The Farm or anything of that description. There is a lauded hospital affiliated birth center nearby but it's not on my insurance plan and I'm not independantly wealthy. ...Oh, now I remember, due to economics, work situation, location and insurance, I have to give birth in a large, American hospital. And now I feel like CRAP about it because I read your book (along with some other books/movies/websites/classes)! I'm now convinced I'm going to be tied on my back to a industrial cot in a cold room, drugged up to the eyeballs with dangerous chemicals and eventually cut open. All against my will. And I can TRY to FIGHT it, but the EVIL hospital POLICY will win in the end. And I will fail, fail, fail. (insert echoing of failure here)
I don't want to feel this way. I don't want to feel like I'm fighting a losing battle. I don't want to "fight" during labor at all. I choose to try to work within the system to try to get the birth experience I want. I choose to believe the hospital staff actually want me and my baby to be safe and happy. What else would you have me do?
and then I stopped writing...
Because it's too upsetting, quite frankly. And I need to start trusting my choices and the people I've entrusted with our care. I need to stop questioning and doubting everything they tell me...every test they order...every strange look I think they've given me or my chart. I've done my research. I know how I would like my birth to enfold, but I also trust that these wonderful midwives that I've chosen also have my best interests at heart (backed by a whole lot of experience and training) even if they do work in a hospital.
In fact, it's okay that I'm giving birth in a big hospital. It doesn't make me an irresponsible mother. And it doesn't mean I'm going to have a nightmare experience. I still intend to have a birth with minimum interventions using hypnobirthing techniques. My birth is going to be beautiful. Full of peace and joy. So, both sides can EAT IT! Ah, that felt good. Trusting myself and my husband and my birth attendants feels good. I am capable of empowering myself with education and positivity and trust. I choose to mix informed decisions with TRUST! Hear me roar!!!
While I still respect a lot of their philosophy and intentions, I think my full-fledged induction into the natural cult ended during the last class when my instructor showed a movie which included a rather long clip of a baby laying in an empty hospital nursery - bawling, naked and bleeding from a heel prick. I think we were supposed to be thinking "EVIL HOSPITAL! I MUST SAVE MY BABY FROM THE EVIL HOSPITAL!!!"
I just thought... Okay, that's it. Give me an effing break. How manipulative can you be? My intelligence and compassion are insulted. It was propaganda at it's worst. Why does my childbirth story have to have a "baddie" out to destroy me and my baby? What do you gain by instilling such fear? I thought this whole childbirth education process was supposed to relieve fear. My husband said it reminded him of the people on the streets of London pushing posters in your face of mutilated beagles with batteries attached to their exposed brains. Yep. But, it's worse than that really. Doctors and hospitals are not puppy-killers. And I'm done with the scare-tactics.